Roofing advice for Spalding
Why two roofing quotes can be thousands of pounds apart
You get two quotes for the same roof. One is £6,500 and the other is £9,800. It would be easy to pick the lower one and move on, but the gap is telling you something.
Usually the two roofers have not priced the same job. Here is how to find out what is different.
Check what each quote includes
Lay the two quotes side by side and tick off each of these. A missing line is not always a trick, but it is always a question.
- Scaffold, including hire for the whole job and the cost of removing it
- Stripping off the old covering and taking it away, with skip costs
- Replacement of damaged battens, rafters or boards
- The type, make and colour of tiles or slates
- The underlay: breathable membrane or old-style felt
- Ridge, hip and verge fittings, and how they are fixed
- Lead work and flashings round chimneys, walls and roof windows
- Fascias, soffits and gutters, if they are part of the job
- Making good and cleaning up
- VAT, if the roofer charges it
Scaffold is the big one
A UK roof replacement guide says setting up and removing scaffold, plus weekly hire, comes to about £700 to £1,300. If one quote has it in and the other leaves it out, that alone can explain £1,000 of the difference.
The hidden-damage question
Rotten timber is only found when the old covering comes off. Ask each roofer how they will price it. A good answer is a rate per metre agreed in writing, plus a promise to show you photos. A bad answer is, we will see.
Materials and workmanship
Tiles and slates vary in price and in how long they last. Cheaper tiles can be perfectly good, but make sure each quote names what will be fitted. Two quotes that both say concrete tiles may be for different qualities and thicknesses.
Questions to put to both roofers
Once the lists are side by side, ring each roofer back with the same questions. It takes ten minutes and gives you a fair comparison.
- Which of these items is in your price and which is not?
- Will the same people who quoted do the work?
- How long will the job take, and what happens if the weather stops it?
- How do you want to be paid, and when?
- What will you do about the rubbish and the loose tiles in the garden?
- If you find rot, what will it cost per metre?
Write the answers down next to each quote. When you look at them again a week later, you will remember why you chose one.
Do not just pick the cheapest
The cheapest quote is a fair choice if everything on the list is there. If something is missing, ask the roofer to price it so the two can be compared fairly. You can also ask the more expensive roofer whether they can explain the gap. A good roofer will not mind.
Common questions
Is scaffold included in a roofing quote?
Not always. Some roofers include it in the price, and others show it as a separate line. Ask, and make sure you are comparing like with like.
Is the cheapest roofing quote the best one?
No. Pick the quote that lists the work you need at a price that fits the guide figures. A very low price can leave out items that appear later as extras.
More on prices and choosing a roofer
Ask for quotes you can compare
Two quotes are better than one, and two on the same list of work are better still. Starting with a free quote costs you nothing.
Send the form with the main details of the roof and you can compare a free quote with any you already hold.